London (CNN) -- Global media tycoon Rupert Murdoch
is "not a fit person" to run a major international company, British
lawmakers investigating phone hacking at his tabloid News of the World
reported Tuesday.
The ruling could prompt
British regulators to force him to sell his controlling stake in British
Sky Broadcasting, a significant part of his media empire.
The damning report
accused Murdoch and his son James of showing "willful blindness" to
phone hacking at News of the World, and said the newspaper "deliberately
tried to thwart the police investigation" into the illegal activity.
The paper's publisher,
News Corp. subsidiary News International, "wished to buy silence in this
affair and pay to make the problem go away," the Parliament's Culture,
Media and Sport Committee found.
Ofcom, the British media
regulator that could force Murdoch out of BSkyB, said it was "reading
with interest" the report from Parliament.
The agency noted that it
"has a duty under the Broadcasting Acts of 1990 and 1996 to be satisfied
that any person holding a broadcasting license is, and remains, fit and
proper to do so."
News Corp., which Rupert
Murdoch leads as chairman and chief executive, accepted responsibility
for some failings Tuesday but pushed back against some of the more
critical remarks made by lawmakers.
"Hard truths have emerged
from the Select Committee Report: that there was serious wrongdoing at
the News of the World; that our response to the wrongdoing was too slow
and too defensive; and that some of our employees misled the Select
Committee in 2009," it said in a statement.
However, remarks made by some lawmakers after the report was issued on Tuesday were "unjustified and highly partisan," it said.
News Corp. said it had
already acted on many of the failings highlighted in the report, had
brought in new internal controls and is supporting police investigations
into alleged wrongdoing.
Allegations of
widespread illegal eavesdropping by Murdoch journalists in search of
stories have shaken the media baron's News Corp. empire and the British
political establishment, up to and including Prime Minister David
Cameron.
Police have arrested
dozens of people as part of investigations into phone hacking, e-mail
hacking and police bribery, while two parliamentary committees and an
independent inquiry led by Lord Justice Brian Leveson are probing the
scandal.
Testifying last week
before the Leveson Inquiry, Rupert Murdoch admitted that there had been a
"cover-up" of phone hacking at News of the World, which ceased
publication last July.
But Murdoch, who owns
the Sun and the Times in London, as well as controlling The Wall Street
Journal, New York Post and Fox News, said his News Corp. had been a
victim of the cover-up, not the perpetrator.
"Someone took charge of a cover-up, which we were victim to and I regret," he said Thursday at the Leveson Inquiry.
He apologized for not having paid more attention to the scandal, which he called "a serious blot on my reputation."
Tuesday's report by the Culture, Media and Sport Committee is based, in part, on earlier testimony by
John Whittingdale, the
chairman of the committee, said Tuesday that, while there is "no
definitive evidence to prove whether or not James Murdoch was aware of
... evidence which indicated that phone hacking was widespread, the
committee was nevertheless astonished that he did not seek to see the
evidence."
Tom Watson, the Labour
lawmaker who has long been one of the fiercest critics of Murdoch, was
blistering in a news conference announcing the parliamentary findings.
"These people corrupted
our country," he said. "They have brought shame on our police force and
our Parliament. They lied and cheated -- blackmailed and bullied and we
should all be ashamed when we think how we cowered before them for so
long."
But Louise Mensch, a
Conservative member of Parliament who is on the committee with
Whittingdale and Watson, said the report had gone too far.
She was one of the four
Conservative MPs who dissented from the amendment to the report finding
that Murdoch was not a fit person to run a company.
She called the amendment
"faintly ridiculous," given Murdoch's decades in the business, and
accused the Labour members of the committee of pushing through a
"nakedly political" statement.
"The amendments were so far out of left field they made a mockery of the whole thing," she said.
The section declaring
Murdoch "not fit" passed by a vote of 6 to 4, with support from Labour
and Liberal Democrat lawmakers, over opposition from Conservatives.
Committee chairman Whittingdale, a Conservative, did not vote.
The report did not
accuse either Murdoch of misleading Parliament, but said three of their
underlings had done so in testimony to the committee.
Longtime Murdoch
right-hand man Les Hinton was criticized, as were Colin Myler, the last
editor of News of the World, and Tom Crone, who was the paper's lawyer
for decades.
Myler and Crone "gave
repeated assurances that there was no evidence that any further News of
the World employee, beyond Clive Goodman, had been involved in
phone-hacking," the report says. "This was not true and, as further
evidence disclosed to us by the newspaper's solicitors Farrer & Co
now shows, they would have known this was untrue when they made those
statements. Both Tom Crone and Colin Myler deliberately avoided
disclosing crucial information to the Committee and, when asked to do,
answered questions falsely."
Mensch noted that Myler,
the editor of the New York Daily News, "has misled a select committee
of Parliament. I would hope that a little bit of attention would be paid
to the unanimous findings of the committee where named individuals
misled Parliament."
In a statement, Myler
said he stood by the evidence that he gave the committee. "The
conclusions of the Committee have, perhaps inevitably, been affected by
the fragmented picture which has emerged from the various witnesses over
successive appearances and by the constraints within which the
Committee had to conduct its procedure," he said. "These issues remain
the subject of a police investigation and the Leveson judicial inquiry
and I have every confidence that they will establish the truth in the
fullness of time."
The full House of
Commons will have to rule on whether the three committed contempt by
misleading the committee, "and, if so, what punishment should be
imposed," the report says.
"It is effectively lying
to Parliament," Whittingdale said. "Parliament at the end of the day is
the supreme court of the land. It is a very serious matter."
BSkyB shares were up slightly in London on the news. Shares in News Corp., which is traded in New York, closed Tuesday up 2.64%.
In a statement to News
Corp.'s 50,000 employees, Rupert Murdoch said the report "affords us a
unique opportunity to reflect upon the mistakes we have made and further
the course we have already completed to correct them."
He said that it was
difficult for him to read many of its findings, "but we have done the
most difficult part, which has been to take a long, hard and honest look
at our past mistakes."
He continued, "We
certainly should have acted more quickly and aggressively to uncover
wrongdoing. We deeply regret what took place and have taken our share of
responsibility for not rectifying the situation sooner."
He said News Corp.
officials "have gone beyond what law enforcement authorities have asked
of us, to ensure not only that we are in compliance with the law, but
that we adhere to the highest ethical standards."
Rupert Murdoch said last
week that if he had known the depth of the problem in 2007, when a
private investigator and a Murdoch journalist were sent to prison for
phone hacking, he "would have torn the place apart and we wouldn't be
here today."
But he also suggested last week that key parts of the scandal have been overblown.
"The hacking scandal was
not a great national thing until the Milly Dowler disclosure, half of
which has been somewhat disowned by the police," Murdoch said.
He was referring to the
revelation that people working for him had hacked into the voice mail of
a missing 13-year-old who later turned out to have been murdered.
The Guardian newspaper
originally reported that the hackers had also deleted some of the voice
mails left for the girl, leading to false hopes that she was still alive
and deleting them herself. In fact, the messages may have expired
automatically.
Murdoch was also grilled
over his media empire's back-channel lobbying of the British government
and said he learned of the existence of one of the key lobbyists only
"a few months ago."
He said he was
"surprised" by the extent of the contact by the employee, Fred Michel,
with the British government as it considered a bid by News Corp. to take
full ownership of British Sky Broadcasting.
That bid collapsed because of the phone-hacking scandal.
The scandal has also forced News Corp. to pay hundreds of thousands of pounds in compensation to the victims of phone hacking.
Murdoch and his son
James have been hammered over the past year about what they knew about
phone hacking by people working for them.
They have always denied
knowing about the scale of the practice, which police say could have
affected thousands of people, ranging from celebrities and politicians
to crime victims and war veterans.
CNN's Alex Mohacs, Alexander Felton Erin McLaughlin, Elaine Ly and Claudia Rebaza contributed to this report.
No comments:
Post a Comment